Gift guides are about to take over your inbox and feed, and plenty of them will promise to fix your sleep, your hormones, or your skin. Some products have real evidence behind them. Others have a science-sounding label and not much else. This week, we asked our experts how to tell a science story from a sales pitch, and what they’d actually spend money on this season.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

  • A June 2026 study found that about 1 in 3 menopause-related searches in the US, UK, and Australia were for products and services.

  • Julia Loewenthal, MD, says phrases like "reverse aging," "detox," and "clinically proven" without published research should prompt questions before you buy.

  • Andrea Martin, DNP, a Menopause Society Certified Practitioner, says the first question to ask about any product's research is whether it was done with enough people and a placebo group.

⏳ Supplements can promise more than they deliver. Read our piece on why a B12 supplement might not protect your heart.

Why does women’s wellness marketing feel so loud right now?

Marketing to women in midlife and beyond has become a noisy space, partly because of demand. A June 2026 research letter in JAMA Network Open found that by 2025, about 1 in 3 menopause-related Google searches in the US, UK, and Australia were for products and services. But the space isn’t always full of good faith players.

Julia Loewenthal, MD, an assistant professor at Harvard Medical School and primary care provider at Lutanen Health, says a common tactic of brands looking to cash in on this trend is naming a real symptom, like brain fog or hot flashes, then presenting a product as the missing solution. It works, she says, because women's health is under-researched and underfunded, so we don’t have as much accurate data on what does and doesn’t work as we do in other areas of health.

Dr. Frank Agullo, MD, FACS, a board-certified plastic surgeon, says he most often sees products that tout “clinically proven,” “doctor formulated,” or “medical grade” on the label, but while these phrases may seem authoritative, “none of these terms has a defined meaning. For consumers unsure of what to believe, it’s nice to have a doctor’s stamp of approval.” 

So what should we be looking for?

Which label phrases should make you pause?

Phrases like "reverse aging," "detox your body," "balance your hormones," and "breakthrough" are signals to look closer before you buy, says Loewenthal. "All of these phrases do not necessarily indicate the product doesn't have strong evidence, but they should prompt questions," she adds.

Andrea Martin, DNP, CRNP, WHNP, MSCP, a board-certified women's health nurse practitioner and founder of the virtual menopause practice Glow Health, also flags proprietary blends that hide doses. "Real treatments name the molecule, the dose, and the route," says Martin.

FDA language trips people up, too. Loewenthal says "FDA registered" and "FDA compliant" are often used to imply a supplement has been approved to work. But supplements don't need FDA approval before they're sold. And "FDA registered" just means the company sent in some forms, says Agullo.

So, what 3 questions tell you if a product’s research is real?

In general, three questions can separate real research from a sales pitch: 

THE 3 QUESTIONS TO ASK

1 Who was it tested on?

2 How many people took part?

3 What was it compared to?

"A product can cite 'research' that was done on cells, on mice, or on 12 people with no control group," says Martin. And "a study of 20 to 30 women performed by the company and measuring how their skin 'felt' after four weeks is a marketing survey,” adds Agullo.

❝

“If the answer is vague, the evidence is vague,” says Martin.

According to Loewenthal, the first thing to look for, especially for supplements, is third-party testing. For devices and tests, FDA clearance (or sometimes FDA approval) may be available. “But that’s the basic safety check, and I’d encourage women to go beyond that,” she adds. “For a supplement, look at the full ingredient list and the dose of each ingredient. For a test or device, ask whether it has been shown to improve health outcomes, not just tracking a health metric.”

What's worth buying this holiday season, and what’s better to skip?

Loewenthal is particularly cautious when a company takes a normal physiological process, creates fear around it, and then sells a product as the solution. “Menopause and aging are not diseases that need to be reversed at all costs,” she says. Agullo says that while at-home “longevity” and hormone test kits make appealing gifts, one-off saliva and finger-prick tests rarely change women's course of action, and menopause societies don’t recommend at-home hormone tests using saliva. 

❝

“If a product needs a science word to sell itself, ask to see the science. Real evidence is usually smaller and quieter than the ad,” says Agullo.

Instead, Loewenthal would put money toward a yoga studio membership, sessions with a certified strength trainer, or visits with a registered dietitian. Martin's surprise pick is low-dose vaginal estrogen, a prescription she calls the best-supported option for dryness, pain, and urinary symptoms. "It is not glamorous, and nobody puts it in a gift set, which is exactly why it gets overlooked," says Martin. And Agullo says that sunscreen (SPF 30 or higher, broad-spectrum, daily) and a nightly retinoid are the skin-care basics with decades of studies behind them.

Where can you find trustworthy health information?

The best source is a clinician who knows your medical history, medications, and goals, says Loewenthal. To prepare, try The Menopause Society’s find-a-provider tool, which lists certified menopause practitioners, and the NIH Office of Dietary Supplements.

“It can be easy to get overwhelmed as there are many great and many not-so-great clinicians on social media,” Martin adds. “ACOG's patient pages are solid too. I say trust your gut. It usually tells you when someone is scamming you versus actually has your best interest at heart.”

And for skin care and cosmetic procedures, Agullo points to the American Society of Plastic Surgeons and the American Academy of Dermatology, plus your doctor (board-certified, of course), “who won’t be selling you anything that day.”

From the Livelong community

Join us for our next virtual Studio Sessions

We host regular events inside our free community focused on women's health. You can join from anywhere and ask the experts your questions during the session.

THU, NOV 19 · 3:00 PM ET / 12:00 PM PT

TUES, DEC 1 · 11:30 AM ET / 8:30 AM PT

Monthly Virtual Coffee Chat
with the Livelong Circle community

Become a Livelong Ambassador

Livelong Ambassadors help us reach more women with science-backed health information and get exclusive perks for doing it. We're currently accepting Ambassador applications for San Francisco’s Livelong Women's Health Summit® in March.

IN CASE YOU MISSED IT

  1. What should peri- and postmenopausal women know before starting a GLP-1

  2. Your hormones may be changing how well you hear

  3. How Stress Regulation Supports Brain Health as We Age

How did you like today's newsletter?

Login or Subscribe to participate

The information provided about wellness and health is for general informational and educational purposes only. We are not licensed medical professionals, and the content here should not be considered medical advice. Talk to a doctor before trying any of these suggestions.

Reply

Avatar

or to participate